Al-Qumi destroys the lie that nobody believes in the falsification of the codex (Mus’haf)

Abu l-Qasim Al-Qumi writes:

الْأَوَّلُ أَنَّـهُـمُ اخْـتَـلَـفُـوا فِـي وُقُـوعِ الـتَّـحْـرِيـفِ والـنُّـقْـصَـانِ فِـي الْـقُـرْآنِ وَعَـدَمِـهِ فَـعَـنْ أَكْـثَـرِ الْأَخْـبَـارِيِّـيـنَ أَنَّـهُ وَقَـعَ فِـيـهِ الـتَّـحْـرِيـفُ والـزِّيَـادَةُ والـنُّـقْـصَـانُ وَهُـوَ الـظَّـاهِـرُ مِـنَ الْـكُـلَـيْـنِـيِّ وَشَـيْـخِـهِ عَـلِـيِّ بْـنِ إِبْـرَاهِـيـمَ الْـقُـمِـيِّ وَالـشَّـيْـخِ أَحْـمَـدَ بْـنِ أَبِـي طَـالِـبٍ الـطَّـبَـرْسِـيِّ صَـاحِـبِ الْاِحْـتِـجَـاجِ وَعَـنِ الـسَّـيِّـدِ والـصَّـدُوقِ وَالْـمُـحَـقِّـقِ الـطَّـبَـرْسِـيِّ وَجُـمْـهُـورِ الْـمُـجْـتَـهِـدِيـنَ عَـدَمُـهُ وَكَـلَامُ الـصَّـدُوقِ فِـي اعْـتِـقَـادَاتِـهِ يُـعَـرِّبُ عَـنْ أَنَّ الْـمُـرَادَ بِـمَـا وَرَدَ فِـي الْأَخْـبَـارِ الـدَّالَـةِ عَـلَـى أَنَّ فِـي الْـقُـرآنِ الَّـذِي جَـمَـعَـهُ أَمِـيـرُ الْـمُـؤْمِـنِـيـنَ عَـلَـيْـهِ الـصَّلَاةُ والسَّـلَامُ كَـانَ زِيَـادَةٌ لَـمْ تَـكُـنْ فِـي غَـيْـرِهِ أَنَّـهَـا كَـانَـتْ مِـنْ بَـابِ الْأَحَـادِيـثِ الْـقُـدْسِـيَّـةِ لَا الْـقُـرْآنِ وَهُـمَ بَـعِـيـدٌ

“The preceding consists in the fact that there was disagreement as to whether addition to the Qur’an and deletion took place or not. Thus, according to the majority of traditionalists (Akhbari), distortion, addition and deletion took place and this is the most obvious from Al-Kulaini, his teacher Ali Ibn Ibrahim Al-Qumi and the scholar Ahmad Ibn Abi Talib, the author of Al-Ihtijaj and according to the Sayyid (Al-Murtada), As-Saduq, the investigator At-Tabarsi and the majority of the legal theorists have declared its invalidity and the statement of As-Saduq in his Al-I’tiqadat states that with what is found in the traditions – which suggest that in the Qur’an, the commander of the faithful (a. ) compiled, there is an increase that is not found in others, – That it is meant the sacred sayings (Qudsi) and not the Qur’an and this is absurd.” [Al-Qawanin-ul-Muhkamah, Volume 2, pages 321 – 322]

Comment:

The scholars are the heirs of the prophets? Representatives of the Imams? Follow them? Al-Mirza Al-Qumi († 1815) is one of the great scholars of the Hawzah